Clancy Jury Deadlocks; Judge Orders More Deliberation
Clancy Jury Deadlocks; Judge Orders More Deliberation
The News
The jury said it was stuck. The judge told it to keep going.
Jurors weighing whether Lindsay Clancy is criminally responsible for killing her three children told a Massachusetts judge on Tuesday that they could not reach a unanimous decision. Judge William Sullivan did not end the trial. He ordered them to keep deliberating.
"After many hours of deliberation, we are unable to come to a unanimous decision," the jury wrote in a letter to the judge, according to the Washington Examiner. The BBC, which had a reporter in the courtroom, reported audible gasps as Sullivan read the note aloud.
A deadlock is not a mistrial
This is the distinction that matters, and it is the one most likely to get garbled. Sullivan has the power to declare a mistrial if the jury cannot agree. He has not done so. On Tuesday he did the opposite, sending the jurors back to the room.
What is not established
No verdict has been returned on any count. No mistrial has been declared. Nothing in the record made public Tuesday indicates how the jury is split, on which charge, or in which direction — and any account of that division would be speculation. The judge has not said how much longer he will let deliberations run.
Timeline
The jury of nine women and three men began deliberating last week after hearing weeks of testimony from dozens of witnesses, per the BBC.
Reactions
Heather Cucolo, a New York Law School professor and expert in mental health law, told the BBC that deadlocks are not unusual in "complex and emotionally charged trials." If one persists, she said, a judge may issue what is informally called a "dynamite" instruction — in Massachusetts, a Tuey-Rodriguez charge — "to encourage the group to consider alternative perspectives and strive for an agreement while upholding their genuine convictions." She described it as typically a last-ditch effort.
Criminal defense lawyer Elyse Hershon told the BBC she was not surprised by the deadlock. "The facts are difficult and a lot of the evidence is graphic so they have a lot weighing on them," she said.
The New York Post reported that legal experts it consulted see a "very high probability" of a hung jury. That is a prediction from outside the courtroom, not a court finding.
More
Clancy, 36, a former nurse, appeared stoic in a wheelchair beside her lawyer, the BBC reported. She was left paralyzed after jumping from a second-floor window shortly after the killings.
What is actually before the jury
Clancy is charged with three counts of first-degree murder in the January 2023 deaths of her children at the family's Massachusetts home: Cora, 5; Dawson, 3; and Callan, 8 months. Prosecutors say she strangled them with fitness bands.
Her lawyer does not dispute that she killed them. The defense argues she was suffering from postpartum psychosis and could not distinguish right from wrong, and that she should therefore not be held criminally responsible. Prosecutors argue the killings were a calculated, intentional decision.
The available outcomes are not simply guilty or free. A first-degree murder conviction carries a mandatory life sentence without parole. The jury could instead return second-degree murder — a killing with malice or extreme recklessness but without prior planning — or manslaughter, an unintentional killing by wanton and reckless conduct. Both would mean prison. If Clancy is found not guilty by reason of insanity she would not be released; she would be committed to a psychiatric hospital with her status reviewed periodically, and could remain there for the rest of her life.
How long they have been at it
Accounts differ slightly on the count. The BBC, CTV News and Cleveland.com describe three days of deliberations as of Tuesday. The Independent's Tuesday bulletin called it day four. Deliberations ended Tuesday without a verdict and are expected to resume.
Charleston White Arrested Again on Florida Battery Charge
Border Patrol Rescues MS NOW Crew in Desert
Sep 13, 2026
Supreme Court Restores Missouri's Old House Map
Sep 13, 2026
Alaska Drops Felony Voter Charges Against Samoans
Sep 13, 2026
Trespasser Breaches Harris' Malibu Estate; No Arrest
Sep 12, 2026
Hegseth Pressed Downed Airmen Into 60 Minutes
Sep 12, 2026
Houthis Seize Mokha, Choking Saudi Oil Exports
Sep 12, 2026
Altman Rules Out OpenAI IPO This Year
Sep 12, 2026
Jury Acquits Lil Durk in Murder-for-Hire Case
Sep 12, 2026
Judge: Trump Broke Law Halving FEMA Staff
Sep 12, 2026
Maher Calls Democrats' Gaza Genocide Claim a Lie
Sep 12, 2026
Blizzard Revives StarCraft, Sends Diablo to Netflix
Sep 12, 2026
Trump's Queens Childhood Home Sells for $1.93M
Sep 12, 2026
Scientists Find New Virus in Tick Invading US
Sep 12, 2026
Britain Bans Settlement Imports; US States Threaten Payback
Sep 12, 2026
Prison Fire Kills 7 as Kurds Protest Killing
Sep 12, 2026
Kosovo Rallies for Ex-President Before Hague Verdict
Sep 12, 2026
Cruz Booed at GameDay Over College Sports Bill
Sep 12, 2026
Blast Hits Bulgarian Arms Plant Supplying Ukraine
Sep 12, 2026
DOJ Loses Nearly Every Protester Assault Trial
Sep 12, 2026
Sep 13, 2026