Microsoft Exec Called AI Scraping History's Largest Theft

Microsoft Exec Called AI Scraping History's Largest Theft

Satya Nadella, Microsoft's chief executive, in a hedcut engraving portrait seated at a desk with hand raised.
Satya Nadella, Microsoft's chief executive, at a desk during a corporate presentation.Illustration: The Frank

The News

Microsoft employees privately discussed whether OpenAI was involved in the "largest theft of labor in human history," according to court documents unsealed Thursday in the New York Times's copyright case against the two companies.

The unredacted filings also show OpenAI and Microsoft executives describing their AI products as substitutes for journalism, Reuters reported — language the Times and other news outlets argue guts the tech companies' fair-use defense.

In the same filing, the Times alleged OpenAI committed "an astonishing theft of unprecedented proportions" by using millions of news articles to train its AI models.

What the Filings Show

Per TechCrunch, the documents show both companies scraped paywalled Times content, built datasets from it, and warned internally that the practice would gut publishers.

The New York Times, reporting on the records in its own pages, said the material captures worry inside Microsoft and OpenAI about damaging the publishing industry.

Timeline

Sept. 17, 2026

Court documents in the Times's copyright case against Microsoft and OpenAI are unsealed, revealing internal discussion of the "largest theft of labor in human history" and executives calling their products substitutes for journalism.

Sept. 17, 2026

The Times and other news outlets argue in the newly public filings that the quotes destroy the companies' fair-use defense; the Times calls the use of millions of news articles "an astonishing theft of unprecedented proportions."

Reactions

The New York Times and other news organizations say the executives' own words show the companies knew their AI products competed with — and substituted for — the journalism they trained on, according to Reuters.

The Washington Post reported that the "largest theft of labor" line headlined the unsealed document, a sign of how central the internal quotes are to the publishers' case.

Neither Microsoft nor OpenAI offered a response captured in the reporting on the unsealed filings.

What's Next

The fight now turns on fair use: whether a court accepts that training AI models on paywalled news articles is protected, or whether the newly public internal messages undercut that defense.

The case is being closely watched across the news business, where the outcome will help set whether AI companies must pay to train on journalism.

Poll

Should AI companies have to pay news outlets to train on their articles?

Yes — it's their work
0.0%
No — training is fair use
0.0%
Only for paywalled content
0.0%
Not sure
0.0%

Trump Signs Orders Opening Federal Land to Hunters

Report Blames Haitian Police for 164-Death Massacre

Trump Plans First Meeting With Venezuela's Leader

FCC Clears Gulf Money in Paramount-Warner Deal

Disney Hands Streaming Control to Ex-YouTube Executive

Convicted Connecticut Official Flees to Greece

Russia, China Veto UN Monitoring of Iran Sanctions

Trump Aides Researched Whether AI Czar Could Profit

RFK Jr. Tells Anti-Vaccine Group: Trump's a Friend

Man Gets 14 Months for Omar Vinegar Attack

F-16 Crashes in Rural Michigan; Pilot Ejects

US Clears $24.3B F-35 Sale to Saudi Arabia

U.S. Approves Visas for Iran's UN Delegation

Senate Democrat Blocks House-Passed Data Center Bill

Trump Touts 'Major Progress' on Poland Army Base

Knicks Halt Ticket Sales After Pricing Blunder

Rove Backs Texas Democrat Over Bo French

Trump Pulls ICE Director Nominee Amid Senate Stall

Ninth Woman's Body Found Near Johannesburg

AI Leaders Doubt Kill Switch Stops Rogue AI