One Juror Blocked Clancy Acquittal, Jurors Say
One Juror Blocked Clancy Acquittal, Jurors Say
The News
Three jurors from Lindsay Clancy's triple-murder trial say one male holdout kept the panel from finding the Duxbury mother not guilty by reason of insanity — after he had already conceded he had reasonable doubt.
The three women, including the jury foreperson, described the deliberations in an interview with NBC10 Boston that aired Tuesday, four days after Judge William Sullivan declared a mistrial in Plymouth Superior Court.
The jury of nine women and three men deliberated more than 38 hours and told the court it was split 11-1.
The Moment It Collapsed
"He admitted he had reasonable doubt, and I started filling out the forms, I was so excited," the foreperson — identified only as Ronnie, a retired fifth-grade special needs teacher — told NBC10's Sue O'Connell. "There were three forms I had to fill out and I started filling them out, I wrote my signature on each one, and then he said, 'but I'm still not going to say that she's not guilty by reason of insanity.'"
Timeline
Clancy, then a labor and delivery nurse, strangles her three children — Cora, 5, Dawson, 3, and 8-month-old Callan — in the basement of the family's Duxbury, Massachusetts, home after sending her husband out for takeout. She cuts herself and jumps from a second-story window.
Clancy, 36, goes to trial. She admits killing the children; her attorney, Kevin Reddington, argues she is not criminally responsible because she was in the grip of postpartum psychosis and heard a voice telling her to kill her children and herself. Prosecutors argue she methodically planned the killings and understood they were wrong.
After more than 38 hours of deliberation and notes to the court reporting an 11-1 split — with the majority at one point saying the holdout could not follow the law on reasonable doubt — Judge Sullivan declares a mistrial. He orders the jurors' names sealed from the public for two weeks.
Three jurors sit for an interview with NBC10 Boston, describing a deliberation room that turned tense enough for the alternates to hear the arguing through a wall.
Reactions
"He was very arrogant," one of the jurors said of the holdout. "He really did not take anything that anybody said ... He just completely disregarded the information that they gave him." Jurors who are nurses had walked him through Clancy's toxicology report, she said.
A third juror, Paula, who has worked for government contractors, said she wasn't sure "rogue" was the right word for him. The panel read him the legal definition of reasonable doubt over and over, highlighted it and read it again, she said: "He would not interact with us and try to understand."
"He had the hardest time" letting go of the fact that "Lindsay viciously killed her children," she said.
The jurors also described leaning on each other through the ordeal. There were "hugs," "laughter" and "a lot of self-care and group care," O'Connell said of their account. NBC10 Boston said it tried to reach the holdout juror; he has not spoken publicly.
What's Next
The mistrial leaves the case unresolved and open to a retrial. No retrial date has been set in current reporting.
The jurors' names remain sealed for two weeks under Judge Sullivan's order, though the jurors themselves are free to speak publicly about the case and their deliberations — which is how Tuesday's interview happened.
More
The legal question that split the room was not whether Clancy killed her children — she admitted that — but whether her mental state at the time relieved her of criminal responsibility. Under the insanity defense her lawyer mounted, a single juror's refusal is enough to deny both an acquittal and a conviction.
The three jurors were identified in the interview only by first name and occupation: Ronnie, the retired teacher who served as foreperson; Kellie, a retired chef from Plymouth; and Paula, who has worked for government contractors.
Poll
Should prosecutors retry Lindsay Clancy?
Colleges Condemn Students Mocking Kirk Assassination Anniversary
Charleston White Arrested Again on Florida Battery Charge
Sep 13, 2026
Border Patrol Rescues MS NOW Crew in Desert
Sep 13, 2026
Supreme Court Restores Missouri's Old House Map
Sep 13, 2026
Alaska Drops Felony Voter Charges Against Samoans
Sep 13, 2026
Trespasser Breaches Harris' Malibu Estate; No Arrest
Sep 12, 2026
Hegseth Pressed Downed Airmen Into 60 Minutes
Sep 12, 2026
Houthis Seize Mokha, Choking Saudi Oil Exports
Sep 12, 2026
Altman Rules Out OpenAI IPO This Year
Sep 12, 2026
Jury Acquits Lil Durk in Murder-for-Hire Case
Sep 12, 2026
Judge: Trump Broke Law Halving FEMA Staff
Sep 12, 2026
Maher Calls Democrats' Gaza Genocide Claim a Lie
Sep 12, 2026
Blizzard Revives StarCraft, Sends Diablo to Netflix
Sep 12, 2026
Trump's Queens Childhood Home Sells for $1.93M
Sep 12, 2026
Scientists Find New Virus in Tick Invading US
Sep 12, 2026
Britain Bans Settlement Imports; US States Threaten Payback
Sep 12, 2026
Prison Fire Kills 7 as Kurds Protest Killing
Sep 12, 2026
Kosovo Rallies for Ex-President Before Hague Verdict
Sep 12, 2026
Cruz Booed at GameDay Over College Sports Bill
Sep 12, 2026
Blast Hits Bulgarian Arms Plant Supplying Ukraine
Sep 12, 2026
Sep 13, 2026